We'd like a nice, easy-to-read logo with mostly block letters, a little brighter than what we have right now, and that incorporates a wrench of some sort. Either a real one like what we have right now, or one that's part of the logo itself. Maybe outline the logo?
Even though our name is TheMotorBookstore.com, we like to highlight MotorBookstore (see current design).
We may also be open to a design that looks a little on the "classic" side, like those logos from automotive products from the 1950s, for example.
The "Automotive Literature and Repair Manuals" is optional, but if we can get examples with and without the tagline, even better.
Anyway, the best design (in our opinion) will be the one that fits our audience, it's sharp and easy to read, and that fits within the area of our current logo.
Thanks for your interest and best of luck!