This was my first experience and overall it was positive. You really have to think through your brief to get the most out of the designers. That sounds obvious but I can't over emphasize this need. I got a lot of variety in logo designs and I am pleased with my final product. My reason for 4 out of five was because once I started rating the logos, I got a lot of similar logs to the ones I rated highly. This became overwhelming to choose from such similar designs. I would expect the designers to see ratings from their own designs but not others. I believe individual creativity would have been enhanced if this were so and maybe I would have had more of a variety to choose from.